"My soul hurts"

Saveur listed the 100 favorites of the food world. As with any list of favorite items, it is bound to be subjective. For whatever reason, Costco sheet cakes came in at #25. I thought it was a joke.

It seems that the writers of the Los Angeles Times Food Section had the same reaction as I did. So they had a taste test of the Costco cakes in their test kitchen. Apparently, the LA Times isn't as fond of mass market sheet cakes with artificially colored Crisco frosting as Saveur. My favorite line is, "My soul hurts."

We'll pass on the cake
Media Dish, Los Angeles Times

SAVEUR threw down the gauntlet. In its "Saveur 100," an annual listing in the January-February issue of the magazine's "favorite restaurants, food, drink, people, places, and things" from around the world, we were startled by No. 25: "Costco Birthday Cake." A $14.99 sheet cake large enough to serve as many people as its number on Saveur's honor roll? This is a "cake worth joining for," the item assured us. Of course, we had to try it.

Feeling sorry we hadn't invited a football league to join us, we bought and tasted three huge cakes, including the filled white cake with buttercream icing that drew the rave.

We assembled in the Test Kitchen. Slices were cut. A hush went over the room. We picked up our forks and began.

"My teeth hurt," said one taster after swallowing. "My soul hurts," said another. It was heavy and terribly sweet and coated the palate. We wondered whether it would even pass muster with 6-year-olds.

"I don't feel so well," said a third taster.

We looked at the list of ingredients on each of the three cakes. It was long and, frankly, scary.

We asked Times Health Editor Tami Dennis to weigh in. "I'm going to go out on a limb here and say this is not healthy," she said. "Tastes like sweetened Crisco to me."

It did to us too. With a long disodium phosphate finish.